TODAY -

E-Pao! Opinion - Controversial Hydro Electric (Multi-purpose) Project

Controversial Hydro Electric (Multi-purpose) Project

By: Namdingpou Kamei *



The proposed 162.8 metres high Dam at the estimated cost of about Rs 6714 crores to be constructed on the confluence of the River Tuivai and Barak at Tipaimukh in Churachandpur district of Manipur, will bring the following losses and destructions to the people of the surrounding areas especially to people of Tamenglong.

  • A total area of land 286.20 sq. km will be submerged forever.
  • Barak waterfalls and Zeilad Lake, which are connected with the history of the Zeliangrong people, will be forever underwater and all folklores and legends will have no monuments' proof and it will become a make up story for the next generation.
  • More than, 40,000 people will be rendered landless.
  • Eight villages situated at the Barak Valley will be completely underwater.
  • More than 90 villages mostly of Tamenglong district will be adversely affected.
  • About 27,242 hectares of cultivable land will be lost.
  • The township of Nungba sub-division Hqs. And the village along the NH-53 will be severely affected.
  • The dam will bring health hazard, water borne diseases, industrial pollution and other environmental and ecological problems due to increase of water surface.
  • Increase in salinity of ground water will be unsafe for drinking thereby causing a lot of problems to the people.
  • Possibility of frequent occurrence of destructive earthquake in the area.
  • The decision was taken without proper ecological studies. Such will create a big trouble in the future to the people.
  • The construction will directly affect the livelihood of the people. The natural product, which the people depend for every aspect of their economy, will be totally cut off so there will be economic and financial crises.
  • Consequent displacement and destruction of the people by implementing the project will pose a grave thread to the vibrant democratic system of people's right to live.
  • The project once installed will submerge the exotic flora and fauna and rich gene pools as Manipur falls under one of the genetic hot spot zones of the world where rare biodiversity resources exist.
  • There will be problem of displacement, resettlement, rehabilitation, repatriation and development issues.
  • The construction of Dam will be violation of our democratic form of Government's functioning where the indigenous voices are to be taken and considered.
  • It is a total disregard of our Zeliangrong ancient indigenous heritage and reflects partiality of the government.
  • Not only the Barak basin will be affected, it will also affect its tributaries.
I am very much surprised to see that, although there has been so many disadvantages of the Dam the Government is always trying to convince the people showing some good points. Government is for the people and should not go against the wishes of the people.

But our worthy bureaucrats and people's representatives are trying to convince the ignorant people of the District especially the affected ignorant ones by showing some good points leaving all the negative impacts behind the screen.

Aware of the negative impacts, people of Manipur particularly, the people of Zeliangrong are protesting the construction of the said Dam. They have submitted a number of memoranda to the Chief Minister of Manipur even to the honourable Prime Minister of India.

The Government is trying to convince people with all their might to understand the real benefits of the Dam but the people are also really aware that the merit points are much less than the demerits.

In fact, we all must work out merits and demerits before we take up any project. Though it is positive in one side, if the negative impacts are more, we should stop it immediately.

I honestly hope that honourable and respected leaders of Manipur Government will understand the feelings of his people. If they cannot understand and do not act according to the wishes of their people, they are unworthy to be called "the people's representatives" and incompetent to be called "the people's government'.

Manipur will get 182 MW or 406 million Units of electricity free of cost, which is 12% of 1500 MW to be generated from the project. And they also said that NEEPCO who is going to construct the Dam would give compensation to the people affected by the project unaware of the land to be lost permanently.

But I want to say that, we will lose our land forever because of only 182 MW of electricity in return. The compensation promised by the authority concerned will never be compensated with the value of the land, which is about Rs 5.8 lakh per hectare of land.

Job facilities promised by the government will be never for the affected inhabitants, because they don't have a capable person to get the job, the other educated person will take the advantage.

NEEPCO the authority who is going to construct the dam will never be aware of the land submerged since their land will not be affected.

Actually Manipur state and India have already enough dams for the purpose of generating electricity and irrigation. But many of the Dams cannot produce what was envisaged for the lack of proper management.

For instance Loktak Hydro Project could not supply enough power to the state due to poor management, but it has destroyed thousands of hectares of paddy field. Likewise, Khoupum Irrigation Project has become a total failure resulting in the loss of thousands of hectares of wet paddy fields.

It is said that except for the lack of proper management or maintenance, India has already enough dams, which could generate sufficient power for the entire country. Therefore, instead of constructing new dams it will be better to invest the money and technicians or workers in the existing project.

This will solve the problems and will not lose our land, which is the nation's most precious property to be inherited by our generation to generations. We must aim to construct less dam but to generate more power, because the more we build a dam, the more we lose our land forever.

Besides, water conflict has been in existence in many states of India due to the construction of dams without the indigenous people's concern like, Sardar Sarovar Dam (built on Narmada river), Tehri Dam (built on Bhagirathi river) etc. Tipaimukh dam should not be added to them.

One of the objectives of the proposed 162.8 metres high dam is to control frequent occurrence of flood in the Cachar plain of Assam.

However, this will affect a total permanent submergence of about 27,550 sq. kms of land surface in Manipur mostly in Tamenglong district which is against the people's right to live and national policy of Land use and this is also a policy of one sidedness. More land of Manipur will be submerged than flooded plain in Assam for the sake of flood control.

Until now the huge dams on the big rivers were considered very useful from the viewpoint of water utilization. But recent scientific studies have revealed that dams give birth to earthquakes. The soil irrigated by canals becomes infertile in the long run due to alkalization. The dams also restrict the free movement of marine life.

The site of Tipaimukh Hydro Multi-purpose Dam is also said to be highly seismic zone with the Taithu fault almost parallel to the selected location.

So if this dam is built and covered the land by water, there will be frequent occurrences of earthquakes in the region. The proposed site of the Dam falls under major mega bio-diversity zone of the world which will lead to the irreparable loss of natural resources of the mother earth.

Our future life will be threatened by the impact of the dam.


Namdingpou Kamei wrote this article for The Sangai Express. This article was webcasted on December 15th, 2006.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Haraoba #5 : Gallery
  • Dilapidated Samkha Ahan temple
  • Yumnam Nilachandra : Kala Akademi Award
  • Saving the youths from Substance Abuse
  • Let us find a way out from ILPS quagmire
  • Lightning : A major killer
  • The Killing Fields 2016 :: News Timeline
  • Grand Iftar Party At Delhi
  • Gorkha Students Orientation in Delhi
  • Curfew imposed in Thoubal areas
  • Right decision to move on
  • Covering-up exercises
  • ILP: Tribal movement 300th day #1: Gallery
  • Intl Day Against Drug Abuse: Gallery
  • ILP : Protest @Moirang #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur's Doomsday
  • General insurance Importance wrt. Manipur
  • Buddhism differs from other religions #3
  • In Solidarity with Victims of Torture
  • 28 Manipur Cong MLAs in dilemma
  • Sangai finds place in 'recovery' plan
  • International Day Against Drug Abuse
  • Sunset at Loktak : Gallery
  • Is drafting fresh legislation on ILP..
  • Child Trafficking in India : Report
  • Towards a TB free India
  • A String of Pearls :: Poem
  • India cannot disturb Manipur Boundary #2
  • ILP : Bandh @Singjamei #1 : Gallery
  • Andro Girls at DANA cup, Denmark
  • ILP Awareness Programme in Bangalore
  • Small steps to progress
  • ILP Issue : Photos Gallery from 2012
  • Biju Ningombam (Actress) #2 : eRang
  • 'Mid Brain Activation' : Gallery
  • Print media and political activism
  • Framework for a Shared Future #3
  • Inner Line Permit (ILP) :: Timeline
  • Learn from South Korea not just hairstyle
  • Jobs @Eastern Entrepreneurs, Imphal
  • Khamba Thoibi Jagoi #2 : Gallery
  • Interaction Program with parents @Delhi
  • Crippling RIMS for two days
  • Mumbai set for Colours of North East
  • Macabre messiahs
  • Landscape of Dzukou Valley #1 : Gallery
  • Luingam, Pamreiyo :: eMing
  • Great June Uprising #3: Gallery
  • Summer Snow: Portraying Manipur : Book
  • Manipur State Population Commission #1
  • ILPS for valley, 6th Schedule for tribals #2
  • Wari : A collection of stories
  • Failing to define who is a Manipuri
  • Need for an alternative
  • Wanglee village in Ukhrul district : Gallery
  • Constable clash with Police: Gallery
  • Poor Peoples IAS Officer (Armstrong Pame)
  • Heartbroken notes :: Poem
  • Urmila Chanam : Activist wins global award
  • Clarification to JACAATB about misquote
  • Public Hearing on Child Trafficking
  • Requirements for Sky Hospital
  • NSU to be shifted from Manipur: BJP
  • Swu health cloud on Naga accord
  • GK book banned in Manipur
  • Don't hold the future to ransom
  • The hoarding call
  • Singda Dam :: 360° Panorama
  • Shon :: eRang Classic
  • International Day of Yoga : Gallery
  • Film-makers, their father and wisemen
  • Communication ..in patient-centered care
  • Communal Harmony and Integration
  • Khuga Dam canal breach
  • Normalcy at Manipur-Nagaland border
  • Noteworthy initiative from 515 individuals
  • On shaky grounds
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Haraoba #4 : Gallery
  • Great June Uprising #2: Gallery
  • 14th Mega Miss North East : Gallery
  • Petition for talks-JCILPS & JACAATB
  • Discussion on tourism in NE @London
  • Memo to CM on failure of Govt. School
  • 14th Mega Miss North East 2016
  • Leimaram Waterfall - Aerial video
  • ILP Demand - Photos from 2012 :: Gallery
  • Music mission touches a special heart
  • Contrasting voices from the hills & valley
  • The rising crescendo
  • Dzuko Lily @Dzuko valley #1: Gallery
  • ILP : Women protestors [Jun 15] #2: Gallery
  • Elimson Maram : Kala Akademi Award
  • Murphy's Law always happens to me
  • Why Manipuris should stop bandh culture
  • Vaccine Logistics & Cold Chain Managers
  • 7th Men Mega Mister North East
  • Tributes in the valley, shutdown in the hills
  • Great June Uprising #1: Gallery
  • Violation of older people's human rights
  • Diseases of Tonsils
  • Should I blame on Google or Govt?
  • ILP Seminar in Bengaluru
  • Uncertain future awaits women's boxing
  • India, Thailand to expedite highway work
  • And divided we fall
  • The Great June 18 Uprising
  • June 18 Uprising :: Flash Presentation
  • 2001 News Archive : June 18 Uprising
  • Photo Gallery : June 18 Uprising
  • Tamei in Tamenglong #2 : Gallery
  • Brand's Harbinger- Celebrities, Bloggers
  • World Day to Combat Drought
  • JAC against 'anti-tribal' Bills-June 17
  • Jobs at Virgo , Imphal
  • Drug abuse and opium cultivation
  • Responsibilities before rights
  • Oral History role in communal harmony #2
  • Soccer Festival @Andro: Gallery
  • Ha Long Bay Vietnam #2 : Gallery
  • Win-win solution to 3-controversial bills
  • The Second Life :: Poem
  • Biking expedition by 4 woman bikers
  • National film awardees felicitated in Imphal
  • From SoO pact to political dialogue
  • Deliberate dementia
  • Eibusu Yaohanbiyu #1 :: eRang
  • ILP : Women protestors [Jun 15] #1: Gallery
  • India cannot disturb Manipur Boundary #1
  • Can RSS Repeal AFSPA?
  • On the 3 Bill & present imbroglio
  • Ganja may be made good for bandhs
  • Guest Faculty at Sikkim University
  • New aviation policy to boost NE connectivity
  • Sharmila- repeal AFSPA :: News Timeline
  • AFSPA and 'attempt to commit suicide'
  • Need for shift in focuss
  • Irom Sharmila @CJM Court: Gallery
  • On a new planning : Changing policies
  • Stealing: Zero tolerance at Ima market
  • Flood in valley, landslide in hills : Poem
  • Blockades and counter blockades
  • Honor women's rights not her womb
  • ILP : Counter economic-blockade : Gallery
  • People's Convention for United Hills & Valley
  • Some thoughts on ILP
  • Butterfly Man of India's latest flutter : Book
  • Tryst with Alzheimer's disease
  • Open letter from father to daughter
  • Protests against crackdown on Students
  • Re-organisations of districts & ethnicity
  • Playing with sentiment of common man
  • Ibudhou Thangjing Haraoba #3 : Gallery
  • Tamei in Tamenglong #1 : Gallery
  • Policy to Alleviate Water Problems
  • The street women vendors in Imphal #2
  • Manipur As Seen By Meiteis, Nagas & Zo #2
  • ILP na maram oiraga maheiroi....
  • Gorkhas At People's Convention, Delhi
  • Blockade affects railway projects
  • IM condemns 'provocation' by ACAUT
  • Idea of Manipur & elusive consensus
  • Wanglee-Namlee Road condition: Gallery
  • Tingjin-Puong :: eRang Classic
  • To Educated Youths Of Manipur
  • Soyam Sweety - Actress :: eRang
  • Irawat & political movements in Surma #4
  • ILP: Meira Rally- 1 June #3 : Gallery
  • Career option in Mass Communication
  • Admission at JCRE Skill Solutions
  • Threat to press - threat to society
  • Singju Fest @Lamlai #3: Gallery
  • Phuritshabam Chandra : Akademi Award
  • Jiribam Wallpaper #8 : Download
  • The spirit of Research & Development
  • Research & Developement: Gallery
  • ILP: Water Cannon to Students #3: Gallery
  • Imphal Municipal IMC election #2 : Gallery
  • ILP : Protest Rally -June 1: Gallery
  • All Party Delegation - June 7
  • JAC against 'anti-tribal' Bills - June 7
  • ILP: Human Chain by Students : Gallery
  • Aspects of Meetei Yumjao : Gallery
  • Tribal Dance @Khunthok Hanbi: Gallery
  • Eyek Tamba :: Learn Manipuri script
  • ILP: Meira Rally- 1 June #2 : Gallery
  • Wrestling at Purul Paoki : Gallery
  • ILP: Water Cannon to Students #1: Gallery
  • Namlee Village Ukhrul :: 360 View
  • Jiribam-Silchar passenger train : Gallery
  • Shree Shree Govinda Temple : Gallery
  • Class X results @ BOSEM : Gallery
  • HSLC :: Top 25 Rank Holders
  • HSLC :: Statistics /Subject Topper
  • HSLC: Roll No Listing
  • HSLC External Exam 2016 Result
  • Manipur Phone Directory :: e-pao Tools
  • Maring War Dance :: Ooba Video
  • Class XII Results 2016 : Pass Percent
  • Class XII Results 2016 : Info
  • Class XII Results 2016 : Science
  • Class XII Results 2016 : Commerce
  • Class XII Results 2016 : Arts
  • Download :: PMP Bill 2015
  • Download :: MLR&LR Bill 2015
  • Download :: MSE Bill 2015
  • SPONSORED ADS