TODAY -

E-Pao! Essays - I,robot....you,robot?

I,robot....you,robot?

By: James Vaiphei *



Why are we so interested in robots?
To be honest, when you come to think about it, It's a bit odd that we are. Robots of the kind shown in the newly-released film I,Robot don't exist in the real world,and aren't likely to for quite some time. Yet robots have been a staple of science fiction, and things very like robots have haunted people's imaginations since long before science fiction.

The thirteenth-century magician Albertus Magnus was a reputed to have built a brass head that talked. The Jewish legend of the golem-a clay man. said to have been built by the Rabbi of Prague is just as medieval. Tom standage's wonderful book The Mechanical Turk tells the story of the many 'automata' built in the eighteenth century, one of which-the chess-playing mechanical man of the title-entertained and baffled the crowned heads of Europe. It was a clever fake, but the lessons learned in building such ingenious contraption become an engine of the Industrial Revolution.

Science fiction actually can't tell us very much about robots in the real world. Reading Isaac Asimov won't help you design a production line, but from its themes we can work out what our interest in robots tells us about ourselves.

Our ancestors were predators who had to avoid becoming prey. This makes us pattern-recognising animals,and easily-startled animals. The patterns we are best equipped to recognise are those distinctive of other animals, and especially other humans.

We see faces in fires, in clouds, in leaves. We're language-using animals, social and sociable, and our faces and their expressions literally mean a lot to us. We're also tool making animals,with an opposable thumb and flexible hand unique in the animal kingdom.

So the idea of a tool, a machine, that mimics our most distinctive features-a machine with a face, a voice, a mind, a hand is disturbing and uncanny. I recently visited an exhibition with many toy robots, and it was interesting to see how much design effort had gone into making them less frightening, indeed cute, for young children, and how easy it was to make those for older children look scary. Robots can give us the creeps.

Where did they come from?
The robot in sci-fi has a double ancestry.One forebear is the monster in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. The other is the real practice of building automata. The Frankenstein motif of creation that destroys its creators appeared in Karel Capek's play R.U.R ( for 'Rossum's Universal Robots', which is where the word 'robot' comes from) and rampaged through early SF.

A more sympathetic portrayal came with the half-forgotten writer Eano Binder's I,Robot and was carried forward in Asimov's stories under the same title. Asimov, you might say, wrote the book on robots, but other stories also stand out.

Anthony Boucher's brilliant theological fable The Quest For St Aquin asked whether a robot could be religious. Brain Aldiss's hilarious and elegiac But Who Can Replace a Man? asked whether robots would miss us if we went. From the 1950s to the 1970s,robots carried a heavy weight of themes-humanity,identity,labour,slavery-on uncomplaining metal shoulders.

The emergence of Al
And then they went away. They become,as sci-fi writer Paul MacAuley once said,dead tech,an outworn idea that serious sci-fi writers couldn't write about with a straight face. They died and went to heaven, which for robots is the silver screen.In satirical series like Red Dwarf and sci-fi movies like Star Wars, they can entertain a whole new audience from whom the robot is still new.

What's replaced the robot as a serious topic is Artificial Intelligence. The research into cognitive science that underlies Al gives us a deeper answer to the question I started with. It tells us that minds are built out of mindless little bits.

Synapses in our brains and logic gates in computers are doing the same kind of job. Computer don't have minds yet, but some day they may. If we choose to give them machines to move around in, we'll have robots.

Until then, one place where you can see a body controlled by machine that thinks for itself is in the mirror we are interested in robots because we are robots.




* James Vaiphei, Student and Member of Institute for the Management of Information System (IMIS) writes regularly for e-pao.net.
He can be contacted at [email protected]

* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Early History of Manipuri Sahitya Parishad #3
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2026 : Timeline
  • Oken Amakcham (19622026)
  • Tribute to football coach Oja Kamini Kumar
  • Tobacco products demand in Manipur
  • Live Laser Proctology Surgery performed
  • Film Appreciation Course at MSFTI
  • Tripura Wins Best National Costume 2026
  • Demonstrating merit of team work
  • The Forgotten Kings : A Hearthside Story
  • Linthoi Chanambam : Gold at Asian Judo
  • 4th Phase "Ningol Van" at Golapati Hatta
  • We are just 33 lakh
  • Monsoon skincare tips for babies
  • Call for closed door meeting with CSOs
  • Trouble makers with an agenda
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #2
  • The politics of devotion & syncretism
  • Sunita- Best Manipuri Film @72nd Nat'l Award
  • China-Myanmar with a Shared Future
  • North East India Festival 2026 at UK
  • A gory slaughter :: Poem
  • Kang Chingba @Thangal Keithel : Gallery
  • A World Cup football final 40 years ago
  • Manipur needs a livelihood policy, not relief
  • The Puzzle Unsolved :: Poem
  • IndiGo from T2 Terminal Guwahati Airport
  • Manipur Electricity Regulations, 2026 draft
  • India's Tribal Perspective to 19th UN EMRIP
  • Imphal, Delhi : Losing the plot
  • Kang Chingba @Govindajee Temple : Gallery
  • Kanto Sabal & security questions
  • Rights of Freedom of religions & beliefs
  • Lord Jagannatha's processional chariot fest
  • Condemns Kanto Sabal Arson Attack
  • Love Will Find a Way :: Poem
  • Naga Peace Process: Indo-Naga Talk: Timeline
  • The killing and anti-AFSPA stand
  • 77th Republic Day @ Kangla #3: Gallery
  • 2004 Kangla Protest: Anti-Repression Day
  • Make every effort to do what leads to peace
  • 'Trust Deficit Towards Govt of India'
  • On the grand road of Puri
  • Day 2: Hands On Training- Yelhou Hidak 2026
  • 23rd Technothlon at Techniche IIT Guwahati
  • Playing the victim card will not do
  • 63rd Mr Manipur @ MU #5 : Gallery
  • Thotmungam, Taibanganba, Reichan : Eming
  • Thank you, Cristiano Ronaldo
  • Ethics of financing armed groups in Manipur
  • Dylan Thokchom @ Badminton Asia C'Ship II
  • What do recent initiatives of young people say?
  • Day 1: Hands On Training- Yelhou Hidak 2026
  • Of health, water & power supply
  • Cultural @ Beating of Retreat #3 : Gallery
  • Underpaid nurses : A look at pathetic salaries
  • Manipur : Living under shadow of violence
  • Wild Nature :: Poem
  • Fulfil the 2027 #EndTB commitments
  • Walking Lens 3.0 concluded
  • Up in flames since May of 2023
  • Seasonal Fishes @Ima Keithel #3: Gallery
  • Meetei Mayek High School : Subroto Cup
  • Trend of mislabelling in recent times
  • AI revolutionize early disease detection in crop
  • Khemchand the Sardar Patel
  • 4-year integrated teacher education (ITEP)
  • Fibre Economy: India's next big opportunity
  • Right under the nose of Army : Leimakhong
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self #1
  • The names behind the arrest
  • 2026 FIFA World Cup - new global standard
  • 10th NE Int'l Fashion Week 2026 announced
  • A girl in the temple :: Poem
  • 'Overwhelming Meetei Support For ST Status'
  • Oncology OPD Services launched
  • 77th Republic Day @ Kangla #2: Gallery
  • National Drone Innovation Challenge 2025-26
  • The Next Market Day :: Poem
  • Manipur airfare crisis: Way out is beyond reach
  • Posts @ Dept of Art & Culture, Manipur
  • Monsoons beauty
  • Transformative journey on Reform Express
  • Reading the stand of the Kuki CSO leader
  • Early History of Manipuri Sahitya Parishad #2
  • 35th NAMA Annual Convention at New Jersey
  • British Coin Puzzle
  • The story of Citrus
  • Pride Ride 2026 Pedals in Agartala
  • BRICS & the New Geography of Agri-Trade
  • Seeing, treating all as equals
  • Unravelling the knot: Reclaiming Thaksi-Khasi
  • The making of a Social Worker
  • Enough is Enough :: Poem
  • Online submission- Class XI & XII to COHSEM
  • Rising above HIV diagnosis
  • 12 years of Science in service of India
  • Six Naga men : The hurt, pain still lingers
  • Solo Dance: Wahengbam Debina #2: Gallery
  • Dylan Thokchom @ Badminton Asia C'Ship
  • 'Imp-Jiri Highway to Be Ready by Dec 2026'
  • Reassessing Manipur's geopolitical conflict
  • A Walking Life :: Poem
  • Something on Scrub Typhus
  • Making it to the news for right reasons
  • Yumjao Lairembi Haraoba #2 : Gallery
  • Border Flames: CoBRA, Crisis in Kamjong
  • A Fool's Cry :: Poem
  • Manipur Displacement Crisis- Security Failure
  • Why are we still not on track to end TB
  • Development Vision for Assam & North-East
  • Delhi: Noting new area of conflict
  • 63rd Mr Manipur @ MU #4 : Gallery
  • Hundred Flowers Institute of Medical Sciences
  • 3rd 'Ningol Van' Tree Plantation at Kongba
  • Possible way out of festering conflict
  • Draft Electoral Rolls for Imphal West
  • 3 ACs - Draft Electoral Rolls for Senapati
  • Draft Electoral Rolls for Imphal East
  • The sunshine of civilization :: Poem
  • Working on a Saturday
  • Present signature for February 30 !
  • Boy Who Dredged the Rivers: Taothingmang
  • Day 3 : Yaoshang Festivities : Gallery
  • Golden Jubilee of JNMDA (Prod Unit)
  • The failure of selective liberalism
  • Apatani's Next Top Model 2026 : Grand Finale
  • The Faithful Pen :: Poem
  • Obesity - Mother of many lifestyle disorders
  • Fuzzy Clearances in Mapithel Project
  • E20 Petrol in India: Controversy Behind Biofuel
  • Ratify UN Convention Against Torture
  • When Manipur University says No to Drugs
  • Teaching : The most judged profession
  • Cloud of Death: Tobacco's Global Shadow
  • Time to show there is a Govt in place
  • World Environment @Lamdeng #2 : Gallery
  • Why Kuki failed to co-exist with communities
  • Apatani Fashion Week 2026 at Hija
  • Admission Notice : Dhanamanjuri University
  • 41 yrs of healing lives & strengthening Manipur
  • Smart protected cultivation : For climate smart
  • Heatwave makeup guide
  • Call for conscientious voting
  • Ningol Phida @Shumang Leela #1 : Gallery
  • Two civil society reports on violence in Manipur
  • Influenza : A potential for another pandemic ?
  • Who Shapes Whom ? :: Poem
  • Rejects KZC's June 25 Press Conference
  • Science behind the RSS Shakha
  • Paradox of devotion, power of babas & justice
  • Impact of inter-district blockade
  • Day 3 : Yaoshang Sports : Gallery
  • World Motor Cycle Day @Andro : Gallery
  • SoO & selective law application
  • New thaw of Indo-Myanmar relationship ?
  • Transparency in rehabilitation centre evaluation
  • Mother Earth :: Poem
  • Patriarchal resistance in Africa- gender equality
  • After Sharda who, is the question
  • Sillam Sintha Jagoi @ATINGA : Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2026 #3: Gallery
  • Constitutional and federal discourses
  • Guru Shishya Parampara Scheme 2026-2027
  • The Personal MBA is no less than an MBA
  • A surge of love :: Poem
  • Walking Lens - 3rd Edition
  • Selling false sense of normalcy
  • Ethnic conflicts & effects on local fisheries
  • July Calendar for Year 2026 : Tools
  • Seminar: NE Traditional Knowledge System
  • Youth, Education & the Road to Peace
  • I Will Not Be a Footnote :: Poem
  • Rejects KZC's Contradictory Statements
  • Being Indian/Manipuri citizens
  • The politics of shutdown & blockade
  • 360° panoramic view of spots in Manipur
  • Tangkhul Meiphung: The wounds of Time
  • Arambai Tenggol & the law of defence
  • SWC Khongman Mourns Demise of Founder
  • A New Skyline for Imphal
  • Legal for Inmates of Manipur Central Jail
  • Demands Abrogation of SoO
  • How Football Connects Us Across Generations
  • Homecoming @ Washington DC : Gallery
  • BSc (Horticulture) State Govt Nominee
  • The World Drug Problem
  • Senior Media Delegation Visits Karkinos
  • Why is interest on education high ?
  • Guwahati Airport Emergency Response
  • Admission without a shred of guilt
  • ANSAM Rally demanding justice : Gallery
  • Imokanta's Shumang Lila of Manipur : Review
  • Drug addiction is a disease that can be beaten
  • KZC's 25 June PR Exposes Brutality
  • Awareness Programme on Drug Abuse
  • Three-day Rise Up Summer Camp 2026
  • Tips for healthy & beautiful nails in summer
  • The yarn about return of peace
  • Workshop- 'AI in Journalism' : Gallery
  • Exploring The Vanishing Self - Book Launch
  • The Great Regression of Manipuri Cinema
  • A venture on culinary enterpreneurs
  • A convoy that deepened fears of proxy war
  • Offering :: Poem
  • Forgotten dialogues convened at Delhi
  • 25th The Great June Uprising #2 : Gallery
  • Day 2 : Yaoshang Mei Loukhatpa : Gallery
  • How Manipuri Cinema is Reimagining Future
  • A Dime A Dozen # 1 : Author's Warning Note
  • 3 yrs on, Manipur demand an honest reckoning
  • Financial traps you should avoid
  • NE India Infrastructure Summit 2026
  • Stand to contest coming Assembly polls
  • Manipuris (Meitei) and Bishnupriyas
  • Kamesh Salam Recognized by Business Today
  • Manipur's children are watching
  • Nungshiba Leinamna : Weaves Love & Legacy
  • The albatross of mid-June :: Poem
  • On Working Committee, NNPG's statement
  • Workshop : Application of AI in Journalism
  • Emergency shutdown politics of CoTU
  • 26th Death Anniv : Arambam Somorendra
  • Yaoshang Pechakari @ Govindaji: Gallery
  • Understanding infertility in a changing world
  • The Cry of My Six Brothers :: Poem
  • ANSAM rally at Imphal : Call of indigenes
  • Candle Light Vigil @ New Checkon : Gallery
  • B.Sc @ CMC College of Nursing, Koirengei
  • Cultural @ Beating of Retreat #2 : Gallery
  • Tree Plantation Drive @ Mekola : Gallery
  • 35th State Thang-ta Championship 2026
  • 25th The Great June Uprising #1 : Gallery
  • AMD Academic Accelerator Program, Pune
  • Manipuri and Bishnupriya Manipuri
  • June 18 : A Day of Unity, Sacrifice
  • Protest erupted @RIMS [15 Jun] : Gallery
  • Massacres perpetrated by Kukis during British
  • Khuiyoi Tompok & Sound of the Drum
  • 28th Meira Paibee Numit @Khurai : Gallery
  • 3rd anniv- Khamenlok 'massacre' : Gallery
  • Healthcare for Manipuris in Bangalore
  • AI : Explore 25+ yrs of Manipur archives
  • Remains of 6 Naga hostages @JNIMS: Gallery
  • The Lost Paradise
  • Moirangthem Chandra's collection of Puyas
  • What Manipur conflict reveal about oppression
  • 'No NRC Update No Census' Rally : Gallery
  • Yaoshang Mei Loukhatpa #3 : Gallery
  • Showcasing Manipur @Switzerland : Gallery
  • 1st Peaceful Coexistence Award 2026
  • Events- Kuki militant & Naga village volunteer
  • Martyrs' Day @ Cheiraoching #3 : Gallery
  • The King Who Came from the Sky: Pakhangpa
  • Chakan Gang-Ngai 2026 : Ooba Video
  • >
  • How to Break Manipur w/o Breaking Any Laws
  • 17th Manipur State Film Awards (MSFA), 2025
  • Eid-Ul-Zuha @Sangaiyumpham : Gallery
  • 16th Manipur State Film Awards (MSFA), 2024
  • Radio E-pao: 5 new songs updated
  • Yaoshang - Cooking Competition : Gallery
  • Manipur State Award for Literature 2024
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Full Result
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Pass % : Govt Schools
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Pass % : Aided Schools
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Pass % : Private Schools
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Withheld-students
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Compartmental candidates
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Statistical Abstract
  • HSLC Exam 2026 : Important Information
  • Tronglaobi: 2 children laid to rest : Gallery
  • Free Online access to 'Asangba Nongjabi
  • Final Merit List : Manipur Civil Services 2022
  • Killing of 2 children @ Tronglaobi : Gallery
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #3
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #2
  • PUCL Tribunal report: A shadow of partiality #1