TODAY -

Open Letter to V Shanmuganathan (Governor of Manipur) on the Definition of Culture
- Part 1 -

Kshetri Prem *

V. Shanmuganathan : Governor of Manipur
V. Shanmuganathan : Governor of Manipur :: Pix - DIPR



An Open Letter to His Excellency, Shri V. Shanmuganathanji,
Governor of Manipur and Meghalaya
on the Definition of Culture


Your Excellency

I do not know if I could qualify as one of the possible candidates for the 'hundred words challenge' on defining culture posed to the audience of the 12th August gathering by Your Excellency because I was not present in the inaugural function of the Manipur University of Culture and the Manipur State Film and Television Institute. I am afraid that this open letter would turn out to be what we understand as 'chhoti muh badi baat' because in that august gathering where you asked to write an essay on culture there were at least two Padmashrees (an internationally acclaimed film maker, and the other an international figure in Manipuri culture).

Those present in that crowd were 'living heritage(s)', Sahitya Academy awardees, cultural activists, theatre and film personalities, kritan gurus, Manipuri dance gurus, academicians, one Vice-Chancellor ... Yet, I could not stop myself from trying to claim your 'once-in-a-lifetime tea (Chinese drink brought to India/Bharat by the British) with the Governor' offer by writing this essay for your kind perusal (14th century English lexical borrowed from Latin which the British made us use along with phrases like 'I beg to state'). I also beg to state that hundred words will not be enough to define culture, so kindly allow me to exceed the hundred word limit and discuss why culture cannot be explained in hundred words.

I still remember a joke cracked by a very good friend (A Bengali born in Bihar presently teaching in Africa) when we were at Hindu College, Delhi University. The joke goes something like this; "Why there is no culture in North India?" asked one South Indian to a North Indian. The North Indian replied, "While we were constantly fighting foreign invaders and defending India (Bharat) you had all the time and pleasure to play mridangam and do Bharatnatyam." I was not aware of the hegemonic overtones that run through that joke which is primarily designed to stimulate laughter and please our senses momentarily or otherwise. However, I understood the cultural contestation being played out (in and around the joke) and the shallowness with which we have received and perceived the notion of culture in this part of the world.

Your Excellency would recall the statement made by the RSS Chief Shri Mohan Bhagawatji on 1st January, 2013 at Silchar, Assam in which he spoke about the difference between Bharat and India. The ensuing debate on India vs Bharat and rapes in India (not in Bharat) gave India some sound-bites. My focus is on the underlying meaning of 'India as opposed to Bharat'. 'Jaha nei Bharate, taha nei Bharate' is a Bengali proverb. It means, 'what is not mentioned or not there in Mahabharata is not to be found in Bharat'.

By extension, it means that the values and ideals depicted in Mahabharata (and Ramayana) should be every Indian's way of life. Those who do not adopt these values and ideals are Indians (as opposed to Bharatiyas) and, hence, do not conform to the Bharatiya way of life. These are dangerous propositions for a young country like India.

'Jaha nei Bharate, taha nei Bharate' is much more than a proverb. It is an idea which led to the linking of many kingdoms in the Northeast to Mahabharata. Manipur was no exception. Vaishnavite missionaries flouted the 'Chitrangada theory' for Manipuris. According to this theory, Chitrangada, Chitrabhanu's only child (Chitrabhanu being Ananta Naga's great grandson), married Arjuna of the Mahabharata. They begot a son called Babhrubahana. Babhrubahana's son is called Yavistha. Yavistha Deva's other name is Nongda Lairen Pakhangba (33- AD) who is identified by original Meitei chronicle called Cheitharon Kumpapa as the first king of Manipur [1]. This constructed history of Manipur linking the Meiteis to the epics and the puranas immediately denounced traditional belief systems, associated rites and rituals, rites of passage, Manipuri script and literary tradition, etc. The same goes for the other two kingdoms in the Northeastern side of Bharat (Assamese as descended from Bhim, and Tripuris from Yudhistir). Your Excellency has, yet again with this challenge, put us in India, not in Bharat.

Was Sanskritisation of the Meiteis a boon or a bane? I do not have a definite answer. But, reading comments like the following make me think how different communities in the Northeast region of the present day India were imagined and opinions about them were generated and formulated by the so called mainland Indians. Highly subjective observations of one bhadralok named Kshirodachandra Raychaudhuri appeared in 1886 in an article called "Banglar Borbor Jati" ("Bengal's Barbaric Races") in a journal called Nabya Bharat regarding the races in the region. It read:

In the north east, near Manipur, there are many uncivilised races ... the uncivilised people of Chittagong can be divided into two sampradays: Nadiputra and Giriputra. Others included the Jumia and the Chakma Mogs. The Jumias reside in different villages and in each there is a sardar/roaja [village leader] . . . the Chakmas are uncivilised because their marriage customs, dress, and death ceremonies are entirely different from those of the Bengalis. For example, in their samaj men and women meet and dance together . . . they often do naat worship; they are very cruel and do not believe in certain codes of civilised etiquette; they do not respect kings and pradhans. Common civilised forms of greeting by folding hands, or being grateful are alien in their conduct . . . Some sampradays are worse than others. For instance, the Riyangs are the most uncivilised, and the Kiratas are infamous for their lying. [2]

I fail to understand how the Manipuris were excluded from this 'uncivilised' club. It was probably because we were already sanskritised (a term coined by M. N. Srinivas explaining the phenomenon of an upward movement of a low caste to a higher caste, see, Social Change in Modern India) Is it a stray comment? Even if we were excluded, Manipuri etiquettes are different from that of Bengali etiquettes or, for that matter, from the rest of India. Manipuri male and female meet and dance together. Manipuris even celebrate a fertility rite called Lai Haraoba. They do not say Namaste and greet with folded hands when they meet others. The Manipuri food culture, dress, rites of passage, etc. are entirely different from those of the 'others'.

Quite often, like any dynamic society, the people of Manipur revolted against the kings and the ruling class. And, it is common knowledge that we humans have mastered the art of lying. The only race, be it fact or fiction, which do not say the "thing which is not" is the Houyhnhnms only. Such a highly opinionated and, rather, ill informed and colonialist/imperialist observation by the Bengali commentator reminds me of a passage from an essay by Joseph Addison when he warns us, "... we are all guilty in some measure of the narrow way of thinking, ... when we fancy the customs, dresses, and manners of other countries are ridiculous and extravagant, if they do not resemble those of our own." [4]

This takes us to the notion of Bharat or Aryan race. Let's try to define what Aryan is or who is an Aryan.

Caste Hindus were Aryans and Aryans were indigenous to India. Non-Hindus were foreign and these were the Muslims, Christians, Parsis and the Communists as well. All these were aliens since India was neither the land of their birth pitrabhumi nor the place where their religion originated punyabhumi. [5]

However idiosyncratic the definition of an Aryan is in the above statement, the political existence of this region came only after the signing of the Treaty of Yandaboo on 24 February, 1826. So, there cannot be a debate on India being Manipur's pitrabhumi or punyabhumi. The kingdom of Manipur has had a very long history. Cheitharon Kumpapa, the royal chronicle of Manipuri kings, records Nongda Lairen Pakhangba who ascended the throne in 33 AD as the first king of Manipur and Meiteingu Bodhachandra as the last sovereign head of Manipur in 1955. When the authenticity of its historicity before 1485 AD is still under academic scrutiny, however, the accuracy of the royal chronicle after 1485 has been established. Writing in the Manipuri script commenced 'at the close of the 12th century but not later than the 15th century'.

Manipuri, as a language, has a rich oral tradition. And, Manipuri, as a people, are very rich in culture. Like any evolving society, Manipur has seen many changes in the past. From a land of different principalities Manipur emerged as a composite kingdom in the 17th century. Many theories are there linking us to the culture of India from an early stage.

But the real contact, though remotely, began in the 15th century when 'Visnu worship was patronized by the king of Manipur'. It was only in the 17th century that Manipuris came into a long and direct contact with Indian culture and religion. The kingdom changed its religion from Sanamahi Worship to Vaishnavism during the reign of Pamheiba (who his master calls Garibaniwaj) in early 1700s. The British invaded Manipur in 1891. Manipur got independence from the British on 14 August, 1947. Manipur was annexed through 'merger agreement' in October, 1949. So, Manipur carried along with it some 2000 years of history, language, literature, culture when the annexation happened in 1949.

To be continued.....


* Kshetri Prem wrote this article for e-pao.net
The writer is Assistant Professor, Dept. of English, Tripura University and can be reached at kshprem(AT)gmail(DOT)com
This article was posted on August 16, 2016.


* Comments posted by users in this discussion thread and other parts of this site are opinions of the individuals posting them (whose user ID is displayed alongside) and not the views of e-pao.net. We strongly recommend that users exercise responsibility, sensitivity and caution over language while writing your opinions which will be seen and read by other users. Please read a complete Guideline on using comments on this website.




LATEST IN E-PAO.NET
  • Re-Interpretation of Subika Art of Manipur
  • Violence in Manipur 2023-2024 : Timeline
  • International Day of Yoga #2 : Gallery
  • India refugee policy: Rohingyas Vs Chin-Kuki
  • Haats (Weekly Markets) of Guwahati
  • Shillong gears up to host Durand Cup
  • Lip care during Monsoon
  • Gaikhangam in his elements, again
  • The death of a Chiru man
  • Anti-Repression Day @ MDU #1 : Gallery
  • You are wrong, but it's okay
  • Growing call for 100-100-100 to end AIDS
  • Pelvis as the body's emotional junk drawer!
  • World Youth Skills Day & our environment
  • Insanity at its worst
  • 55 kms per day on Imphal-Jiri stretch
  • Justice Kotiswar: First among equals
  • Kang Chingba @Govindajee #2 : Gallery
  • Introducing Thang-Ta in school curriculum
  • N Kotiswar - Judge Supreme Court of India
  • Meitei Professors' Invention Patent [Upd]
  • Boeing crisis hits India, air fares to shoot up
  • Scholarship: Rs 4 crore for civil service
  • Out on the streets against extortions
  • Mandate against party-hopping
  • Birth Centenary of Jananeta Irabat, 1996 : #10
  • Bamboo Bio-toilets at Champu Kangpok
  • Decarbonisation for human survival
  • Book Release to promote physical education
  • "ST status for Meetei" @ Langmeidong
  • Condemns the Killing of CRPF Jawan
  • Rahul Ji, let us talk solution
  • Targeting Central security personnel
  • The monster outgrowing its creator
  • Aftermath of Imphal Flooding #2 : Gallery
  • World Plastic Surgery Day 2024
  • A new front of 'power politics' in Nagaland
  • 2nd Meghalaya Pineapple Fest at Delhi
  • Super 20 batch for UPSC 2025 announced
  • Why is PM not meeting Manipur leaders ?
  • Justice to displaced people
  • Imphal Art College Exhibition #1 : Gallery
  • Scholarship for Johnstone Hr Sec given
  • Will #PutPeopleFirst drive HIV response?
  • Open Letter to Amit Shah, Home Minister
  • The Power of Poppy - 39 :: Poem
  • World Population Day 2024
  • Beating of the Retreat #3 : Gallery
  • Liar's lair :: Poem
  • The Richest Man in Imphal
  • Gamcha, the Assamese Scarf
  • Meghalaya Govt launches OTT platform
  • Comprehensive Coverage in NE Telecom
  • Battered and tattered roads
  • Let there be transparency
  • Kanglei Thokpa @ Sagol Kangjei : Gallery
  • Featured Front Page Photo 2024 #3: Gallery
  • Historic Premiere: 'Chilli Chicken' at Manipur
  • Effective Unified Command for Resolution
  • Music & Quiz: Drug Abuse amongst youth
  • Visionless and headless DMU
  • When is the right time & situation for PM visit
  • Descent of Radha-Krishna #37: Download
  • Inspirations from Scientists of Manipur: Book
  • Manipur crisis: Treat the disease, not symptom
  • 133rd Durand Cup Trophies Flags Off
  • NEET droppers vs freshers
  • Death : Only future to look at ?
  • Mental health of displaced people
  • Aftermath of Imphal Flooding #1 : Gallery
  • When was the last time we smiled ?
  • Appeal to Stop Unbearable Monetary Demand
  • 'Oppenheimer' links with Supreme Science
  • 'Preventing from holding a press conference'
  • Travel tips during Monsoon
  • Look at it via ground reality
  • Making the 'Balak Buddhi' wiser
  • Kang Chingba @Govindajee #1 : Gallery
  • Release Ebo Mili & Stop large dams in ArP
  • Rainforests are the lungs of Earth
  • Education suffering from political interference
  • Inflated bill main vote plank, law dont cut graft
  • From the Lok Sabha to Manipur
  • Third visit of Rahul
  • Birth Centenary of Jananeta Irabat, 1996 : #9
  • International Day of Yoga #1 : Gallery
  • Lord Jagannatha's processional chariot fest
  • World Zoonoses Day 2024
  • PM 'bola' in Parliament
  • Acknowledging the stand of UNC
  • Embracing tree plantation as a new trend
  • 17th N Tombi Equestrian C'ships #2 : Gallery
  • The spirit & the creed of the Olympics
  • Kang Chingba (Rath Yatra) : Book
  • 'Economic blockade: Rumors baseless'
  • The Power of Poppy - 38 :: Poem
  • Balancing children's academic performance
  • Imphal flooded (again) [Jul 3] #2 : Gallery
  • Covid, Ngari, Yu and Loktak
  • Rural people struggling with network problem
  • English certificate courses for BA student
  • 6th July is International Day of Cooperatives
  • Clogging the waterways with plastics
  • Diverting public attention from core issues
  • Manipur Kanba Khongchat #2 : Gallery
  • Gateway of Assam
  • Integrating GIS & EWS for flood management
  • The Dopamine overdose
  • Free workshop on civil service exams
  • Bucket of cold water after a hot shower
  • Breaking the silence
  • Imphal flooded (again) [Jul 3] #1 : Gallery
  • Embracing 'Sharra - Kashar-ot'
  • Drug abuse & illicit trafficking in Manipur
  • Nudity being served to increase followers
  • Record high temperature
  • Bangladesh FM Hasan Mahmud's Riyadh visit
  • Indigenous call for NRC
  • Come home to the electorates
  • Meiteis must unite for survival
  • Flood advisories issued
  • State & District Control Rooms
  • Green Hydrogen for a clean environment
  • Need for an Emergency
  • Monsoons beauty
  • Calling out the indifference of Delhi
  • Questioning the silence with a roar
  • Birth Centenary of Jananeta Irabat, 1996 : #8
  • Problem & prospect of floriculture in Manipur
  • WomenLeaders India Fellowship 2024-25
  • Naga Peace Talks and Narasimha Rao
  • Arunachal Minister visits Oil Palm @Godavari
  • Clear cut stand from the Nagas
  • Crisis resolution in 100-day plan ?
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #2 : Gallery
  • Manipur: A battleground of imperial geopolitics
  • Wangkhem Suresh @ Higher Defence Course
  • Shoppers Stop's 1st Store in Dimapur
  • Stop razing rail station, divert 25k Cr to Signal
  • Has Imphal completely lost the plot ?
  • Time to take responsibility
  • Tarpon chaklen katpa @ Andro #3 : Gallery
  • July Calendar for Year 2024 : Tools
  • Letter to Prime Minister of India
  • International Day of Parliamentarism
  • Skill Development Course at Lumshnong
  • The Power of Poppy - 37 :: Poem
  • Radio E-pao: Manipuri Film OST (130+ song)
  • Manipur Kanba Khongchat #1 : Gallery
  • Multiple Openings @ JCRE Solutions
  • Our mass addiction to predicting future
  • Bonsai - A play with another aspect : Review
  • Timely diagnosis to stop misuse of medicines
  • Impactful tool- Instagram marketing strategy
  • Essence of the June 28 rally
  • Birds of the same feather
  • Scientist of Manipur: Satyendra Thoudam
  • Education and the fate of Manipur
  • Centre not mind talking to Kitovi or Alezo
  • "ST status for Meetei" at Nambol
  • Why Bangladesh urge military diplomacy
  • MoU : Assam Don Bosco Univ with Cambridge
  • Understanding beyond the coup
  • Donning the role of LoP
  • Rally @ Jiribam [June 26] : Gallery
  • Umananda Island- World smallest river island
  • Breaking the impasse
  • Fantasies of a sinister childhood
  • Program: developing women entrepreneurship
  • Microlearning is impacting talent acquisition
  • Looking for the way forward
  • The message
  • Moirangthem Robi - Mr Universe India 2022
  • Parthenium Menace in Indo-Myanmar : Book
  • Respect & recognise domestic worker
  • "ST status for Meetei" at Hiyanglam
  • One test not for India
  • Include tomatoes in your skincare routine
  • Raising ST call a notch or two higher
  • United in grief, but...
  • Panthoibi Phijol Hongba @Mandalay : Gallery
  • Indo-Naga Talks (From 2012) :: Timeline
  • Great June Uprising @Kekrupat #1 : Gallery
  • Ema Panthoibi Phijol Hongba at Mandalay
  • Ibudhou Cheng Hongba #1 : Gallery
  • Ima Keithel flood- May 30 #3 : Gallery
  • Aid to relief camps @ Jiribam : Gallery
  • Bike Rally - Sekmai to Kangla : Gallery
  • Ima Keithel flood- May 30 #2 : Gallery
  • Scientist of Manipur: Laishram Shanta
  • Imphal valley districts flooded #3 : Gallery
  • Ima Keithel flood- May 30 #1 : Gallery
  • Imphal valley districts flooded #2 : Gallery
  • Imphal valley districts flooded #1 : Gallery
  • HSLC (Class X) 2024 : Full Result
  • HSLC 2024 : Important Info & Grading System
  • HSLC 2024 : Pass % : Private Schools
  • HSLC 2024 : Pass % : Aided Schools
  • HSLC 2024 : Pass % : Govt Schools
  • HSLC 2024 : Statistical Abstract
  • HSLC 2024 : Comparative Statement
  • Scientist of Manipur: Jayanta Manoharmayum
  • Scientist of Manipur: Amom Ruhikanta
  • Preserving Thang-Ta :: Rare Photos
  • Malemnganbi Laishram : Science Topper
  • Thokchom Sheityajit : Arts Topper
  • Aiena Naorem : Commerce Topper
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024 : Science Topper
  • HSE 2024 : Subject Pass Percentage
  • HSE 2024 : District Pass Percentage
  • HSE 2024 : Candidates with Highest Marks
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024: Science Full Result
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024: Arts Full Result
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024: Commerce Result
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024 : Arts Topper
  • Hr Secondary Exam 2024 : Commerce Topper
  • Nupi Landa Thaunaphabishing : Full Book
  • A ferocious hailstorm @Imphal : Gallery
  • Scientists of Manipur : Ngangkham Nimai
  • GHOST of PEACE :: Download Booklet
  • List of Kings of Manipur: 33 - 1984 AD